Register Forgot login?

© 2002-2024
Encyclopaedia Metallum

Privacy Policy

Therion > Sitra Ahra > Reviews
Therion - Sitra Ahra

Ill-Starred Child - 75%

Sean16, January 22nd, 2023
Written based on this version: 2010, CD, Nuclear Blast (Digipak)

While we're certainly not starving on Therion these days with the long-winded Leviathan project, perhaps it is, precisely, time to go back to an era when the Swedish occultists still could boast ambition and inspiration together – time, indeed, to go back to the infamous Sitra Ahra, in order to properly give it the rank it deserves in a now 35-years-long discography. Alright, regardless of what may be the "best" Therion album, it's certainly not that one. Alright once more, it features several of these sluggish animals usually known as "fillers", which had been absent from most Therion records before. Still, its poor reception has always seemed to primarily stem from a couple of non-musical reasons which prevented almost everyone from appreciating the music at its face value. First, significant line-up changes with the successive departures of Mats Leven and, most importantly, the Niemann brothers; second, an inane commercial strategy which is worth detailing a bit.

Let's quickly evacuate the line-up question. It could be truly crucial... were we NOT talking about Therion. Because Therion has always equalled to Christofer Johnsson, and no one else. A masterpiece like Symphony Masses – Ho Drakon Ho Megas was recorded right after another complete line-up revolution, while the iconic Vovin was just Christofer Johnsson with obscure studio musicians. I won't deny the importance of the Niemanns, and especially of Kristian's songwriting, in Therion's history, but pretending a Therion album can't be any good without them doesn't make sense. Case closed.

Then came this series of catastrophic statements from the Master himself, of which we'll single out only the cream of the top: Sitra Ahra will be mostly made of re-written leftovers from the Lemuria/Sirius B sessions. No better way of implying you are releasing a B-sides album, of marvellously shooting yourself in the foot. Further embarrassed claims at a so-called Quadralogy – a word which is a linguistic abomination in itself – linking together Lemuria, Sirius B, the quite different Gothic Kabbalah and this very album, could only complicate the matter, certainly not for the better. Add eventually the fact that, at a time when online music was already reigning supreme, a single song, no more, had been released in advance, and that song was the lacklustre title track, and the conclusion was nearly unanimous: Sitra Ahra could not be good.

Looking back with a clear mind, the cardinal sin of this album is its inconsistency. First and foremost, it features three long songs, which show a strong a tendency to relegate everything else in their shadow, especially considering these are intrinsically the best ones. Then it opens on a mid-tempo, tedious track(1), which suspiciously smells of a tired band recycling its old tricks – same old soprano vocals, same old brass instruments section, uninspired riffing, plodding chorus. This wasn't made to put the listener in the right mood, and, indeed, from time to time this impression of a band which no longer cares for where it's going will resurface. High-pitched power metal vocals on 2012, why? Blastbeats and growls coming out of nowhere on Din, why? Don't get me wrong, occasionally injecting some extra energy into an otherwise soft album isn't a bad move per se, and Therion did it right in the past: remember Mats Leven's over-the-top performances on the mid-2000s outputs. Only, Mats Leven was a recurring character all throughout those, not a one-off wonder randomly thrown in the middle of a single song in a misplaced attempt at sounding, somehow, "different".

A couple of other tracks just suffer from songwriting weaknesses. Cú Chulainn could have boasted an effective, addictive chorus... if only this damn chorus didn't take a good half(!) of the total song. Kali Yuga III, which wasn't exactly a new song, was primarily written to complement the two previous Kali Yuga episodes in a live setting, and with its abrupt start sounds awkward as an isolated piece. The Shells Are Open is alright, save for this goofy trumpet sound in the intro, though certainly not the most memorable song Johnsson et al. ever wrote – that one, for once, seems to be an authentic leftover from Sirius B.

Still, none of these weaker points is intolerable, and each time Sitra Ahra rises, that's up to the highest summits. Technically first, it's irreproachable. Forget the Niemanns, their replacements don't pale in comparison – South-American virtuoso Christian Vidal on the lead guitar, the tenaciously old-school pounding Nalle Påhlsson on the bass. The versatile Thomas Vikström is the best thing that happened in Therion's vocal department in years, I've written it elsewhere; the enthusiasm of a teenager in a (then) 40-years old body, the experienced tenor colliding with the heavy metal screamer in the same person, improbable mix who couldn't fit anywhere but in this very band. Soprano Lori Lewis was already a Therion staple at the time, and doesn't disappoint – warm and faintly innocent together. And don't forget Snowy Shaw and his unmistakable croaking voice, who makes regular guest appearances, including a memorable solo performance on the heavily orchestrated Unguentum Sabbati he personally wrote. Shake all of these together with an additional pinch of opera guests and it gives the twisted Hellequin, vocal zenith of the album – crushes everything in Therion's further career, and even a good load of older songs.

Then you get the three long tracks. The closer Children of the Stone, weird 70's ballad featuring the mandatory Hammond organ section, could have been little more than a re-enactment of The Wondrous World of Punt from Sirius B if it weren't for this stroke of genius – the children choir. Now, that's an experiment done right. And of course this couple of long, long journeys through far away, ancient lands, Kings of Edom and Land of Canaan. The latter, especially, is the song; the thing that, on paper, should never have worked: chain of mini-songs featuring, amongst solo vocals battles, deep choirs, flute madness and occasional shredding sessions, the most unexpected instruments ("singing bowl", harmonica, cabaret piano or even accordion for a weird ¾ break), the genuine tour de force was to make all of those fully coherent to create, again, the feel of a genuine, enigmatic journey.

In fact, the apparent contradictions of Sitra Ahra find their natural explanation when one considers it as a transition album towards what should have been another era in Therion's existence – brand new line-up including, for the first time, a dedicated singer, novel steampunk imagery going hand in hand with twisted vocal battles for an overall decadent mood – of which Hellequin may be the best representative. The three long beasts, on the opposite, sound like the glorious swansong of the full-blown symphonic metal sound they were developing since the mid-90s, while the remaining tracks struggle to find their right place in between. Only, this prospective "new era" never developed into anything solid, a few bizarre experiments with French variété songs and a catastrophic attempt at a steampunk opera being everything it would ever bequeath to posterity. Ten years later the band will take a whole turn back to its mid-career sound. Too late?

Highlights: Kings of Edom; Land of Canaan; Hellequin; Children of the Stone.

(1) Which is, incidentally, Thomas Vikström's first writing credit. Again, fantastic singer doesn't necessarily equal original songwriter.

HELL Yeah ! - 96%

EvinJelin, May 17th, 2014

Sithra Ahra… When Therion starts spewing out weird mythological hebrew words, you know the music is going to be awesome.

"Sithra Ahra" shows everything that I like about Therion: an original sound, symphonic yet metal, with very likable melodies and great metal and opera vocals. And of course, the really evil lyrics about occultism, the Klifoth and other things that Therion usually sings about. This time, they're adding witchcraft and mythical stories about Canaan. Oh, and the Harlequin of hell, his name's Hellequin. Cute, isn't it?

But the smart thing about this album is that it doesn't feel like a recycling of Therion clichés. It manages to prove that the band is still so good at playing what they are good at, yet can still make an actually interesting album. And what is interesting about "Sithra Ahra" specifically, well…

It's surely Therion's most diverse album, at least in symphonic metal. It includes a relatively typical symph metal first tack, three songs over 6 minutes, one of them being 10 minutes 33 long, a short and fiery track that could be labelled symphonic black metal, the third song in the Kali Yuga series started in "Sirius B", and one about the prophecies about the end of the world in 2012. More than 4 people sing on this, though you mainly hear a choir and Lori Lewis.

A little note on the vocals: Therion have changed their vocal team on every album, but now, they seem to have found the perfect one. Each vocalist is great, and all their different styles sum up everything that's awesome about Therion. Lori Lewis especially shines with her skilled and clear soprano vocals. Though not Mats Leven, Thomas Vikström has a pretty good power metal voice too. His daughter Linnea doesn't appear much, but she is pretty good and can sing both semi-operatic and a bit heavy metal-ish.

This feels almost like a… travel album. On every way possible. The songs visit different times and places, from ancient Canaan to Kali Yuga which is, according to some, the age we live in. It also travels between types of songs. Considering how diverse it is, it sounds fresh and entertaining, to the point where you could listen to it on holidays to have some fun off work, or while traveling on the road. And like good "holidays albums", it's so entertaining you can't get enough off it and love every minute of it. Yes, as strange as it might sound, that's the effect "Sithra Ahra" has on me. Or it's just an album I'd listen to every day, period.

And finally… No one knows better than Therion how to make both ear-wormy and evil songs. "Unguentum Sabbati" and "Kali Yuga III" are already dark because of their occult/mystic subject matter, but they have a very heavy and eerie sound, which is just perfect. And though the title track sounds might sound like a too average symphonic metal song, the chorus, which tells us to join them on "the other side, night side of the paradise" ("sithra ahra" actually means "the other side"), does have a little satanic side. I'm not sure satanic is the right word, but as I read on wikipedia, Sithra Ahra is the place of "unholiness", which already suggests something evil, or just really edgy ! I'd say these songs are as good as "Rise of Sodom and Gomorrah" and "Wine of Aluqah".

So if you're a Therion fan, interested in all these creepy ancient near-eastern myths or medieval witchcraft, or looking for a memorable album that might make your trip in the eerie mountains less boring and silent… go ahead and follow Therion to the other side !

Ahra-thritis - 60%

Xyrth, December 29th, 2011

Well, if in my review for Therion’s Gothic Kabbalah I said that things would somehow improve on their following record, which is 2010’s Sitra Ahra, I didn’t mean it would be a major change. In fact, the swedes’ twelfth long-play in their fructiferous career is like a condensed version of that preceding fiasco, only that instead of an eighty-plus-minute poor excuse for a double album, we have roughly an hour of some decent highs and very pronounced lows of material. That’s really an improvement on itself, since the agony is fairly shorter and the filler is less. However, the elegance and awe of their glory past is still missing and the cheese that has replaced them is in no short supply here. Those Therion newbies that call this adventurous, progressive and artsy should really listen to the band’s back catalogue to get a hint of what those words really mean. As I have written before, I’m a huge fan of this band, and that’s precisely why I just can't abide worshiping their crappy stuff just because it has their name and logo on it.

So, production and musicianship are excellent here, very suitable for Therion’s grandiose musical display. The problem is that those qualities are of no good when you have a collection of uninspired and uninspiring songs, such as the majority of Sitra Ahra’s tracks. Nevertheless, Christofer Johnsson has yet again found a great ensemble of musicians to give form to this musical vision, and those fans fearing that the departure of the Niemann brothers and Petter Karlsson (who still provides a small contribution here, singing in “2012”) would leave Therion in ruins should rest assured, as Christian Vidal, Nalle Påhlsson and Johan Koleberg are more than capable replacements, and they prove their worth with their metal-solid input here. Påhlsson’s bass and Koleber’s drum conspire to create a rhythmic section that’s precise and interesting, adding some flourishes here and there, instead of just constraining themselves to do their jobs. And the Argentinean’s guitar work is also high quality, from a technical point of view, working proficiently along ringmaster Johnsson to deliver the chops.

Now, we can separate the good from the bad, and since there’s more of the later, I’ll start with that. The opener and title-track is a good example of the poor and meandering songwriting found here. It’s only five minutes long yet it seems to drag on and on without having any real substance to it. Its pretty boring, despite featuring operatic choirs, diverse instrumental passages traversing different genres (metal and beyond) and a symphonic encasing on the background. Another example is “2012” that’s as generic as its title, seeming to be entirely made up of former Therion songs, and featuring a really intrusive violin that feels like it shouldn’t be there. “Cú Chulainn” would be an ok song if not for the awfully pathetic “harsh” vocals, but it actually gets worse, with the extreme cheese-fest that is “Hellequin”, bearing a multitude of laughable vocals of all sorts, or the towering mess that is “Land of Canaan”. That 10-plus-minute mixture of half-baked motifs even features some harmonica that sounds totally out of place in an “epic” that tries to evoke Old Testament ancient times.

Fortunately, not everything is shit, and on the brighter side of things we have the amazing “Kings of Edom”, which being an eight-minute composition and track number two, really is the saving grace of this album. It’s like a more concise and perfected version of “Adulruna Rediviva”, with several distinct and compelling sections morphing into one another with ease. With tight guitar parts, complex rhythmic dynamics and amazing voices this song almost manages to achieve the greatness of Therion classic works. Then, a few steps back in quality, “Unguentum Sabbati” bears decent riffs and good vocals (though I still don’t like Mr. Johnsson’s later set of vocalists), and the closer “After the Inquisition: Children of the Stone” is a calmed and melancholic piece in the vein of “Siren of the Woods”. The fast “Din” is an amusing mixture of power metal riffage, black metal rasps and blast-beats, while both “The Shells Are Open” and “Kali Yuga III” feature the expected Therion elements working in a focused manner to good avail. In fact, I remember listening to the later live, as the swedes played it at a gig in my home city just before this album came out, and it gave me false hopes for a return to form release. Damn you Therion! From now on, I won’t be that easily fooled.

So, as you can see and, what’s more important, hear, Therion hasn’t recovered from their “Gothic Cagada” yet, and are still carrying the stench of their failure. They need to wash it up, let loose the cheese and start analyzing what used to make them one of the most influential and transcendent bands a decade ago. The potential is still there, and we the fans won’t give up on them that easily. The alternative for them is to mimic Metallica and other once-great bands in becoming just an amazing live act living upon their past glories. Let’s hope it doesn’t come to that.

I'm just not feeling this one, guys... - 24%

MasterTherion, June 25th, 2011

Therion is one of the most influential and notable symphonic/operatic metal bands of all time. Who can forget such amazing metal masterpieces as 1997's Lepaca Kliffoth or 1998's Vovin? Even 2008's Gothic Kabbalah, despite some disenfranchised fans labeling the goth-influenced album a "sell-out", was undeniably top-notch. Yes, Therion has had some amazing releases in the past. But the key words in that sentence are "in the past". Sadly, we are no longer in the past, and Therion's latest release is proof that the band no longer has any idea what they're doing.

To be entirely honest, this is a really annoying album, and it is entirely undeserving of the praise it seems to be receiving. It basically feels like an opera album with a little bit of metal tacked on, and even the metal elements feel closer to generic metalcore than the amazing symphonic/gothic metal that brought glory to previous Therion releases.

What good can be said about the album is that even if the music is really annoying and repetitive, the lyrics are still poetically written, the themes are interesting and deep, and the production values are excellent. This does little to save the album since the music is garbage, but it's nice to know that the band hasn't completely stopped trying.

Fans new to this band may be able to enjoy this release, but anyone who is a fan of the band's earier work will be bitterly disappointed. Perhaps the album wouldn't seem as bad if were made by another metal band, especially one without talent. This album might actually be forgivable if it wasn't such a shameful step down from Therion's previous material, but it's hard to be positive about any album that's such a fall from grace.

To fans of symphonic or operatic metal, Therion's latest release might be good for a spin or two, but it's never going to be touched again. Unlike the band's previous albums, many of which were majestic, melodic, and beautiful, this release is forgettable, annoying, and generally not worth the trouble. There might be a few out there who actually enjoy this sort of thing, but I frankly can't imagine why. Skip this mediocre recording and pray that this is just a sad hiccup in the influential symphonic metal band's career.

Join me to the other side - 41%

extremesymphony, February 26th, 2011

So it's three years and Swedish metal giants Therion are on the road again with their album Sitra Ahra. The sound of this album takes the band further away from their death metal roots and the and develops on the sound they achieved on the twin masterpieces of Lemuria\ Sirius B. This album as usual draws influences from traditional heavy metal, power metal, prog metal, symphonic metal but on this album we see a tremendous rise in the influence of opera music over these other forms. The album sounds too light, fluffy, or sometimes even a bit poppish when compared to the band's earlier outputs. OK let's for a minute forget that we are listening to Therion and that the music is atleast supposed to be heavy if not brutal as in the days of 'Of Darkness', still the album isn't enjoyable. Even if we treat this album to be a pure opera experiment, still the songwriting and the arrangements of songs are too poor to take anything seriously.

Among the individual performances the vocals suck big time. As in a usual Therion album there are many types of vocalists used, but on this album none of the vocalist manages to bring out a dark, occultic feel as was the case with their earlier vocalists. The guitar work is not quite inspiring either and much simpler than their earlier outputs. The lead work is good if not great. The drum is again OK and suffers mostly because of the "I have heard better" syndrome. The orchestra used here is pretty weak. The orchestral melodies are not even a shadow of the band's past and many times the orchestra actually makes the music poppy rather than creating a dark, mystic atmosphere. The production is pretty weak too. The guitars drowned down in the album in favor of the orchestra. The music looses whatever heaviness it would have had due to this.

As already discussed, the music is further away from Of Darkness and is more opera inspired. It seems many a times that Christofer Johnsson after a night of heavy opera overdose wrote a complete opera album. But the after writing the whole stuff he remembered that Therion is actually a metal band, so in come guitar riffs, solos, drum work of such poor quality which will make your latest 'troo' metalcore band swell with pride at their output. The earlier Terion albums used to have a magical, occultic atmosphere about them thanks to excellent arrangement of orchestra, superb lyrics and strong vocal performances. Here the all the above elements fail to do their respective jobs. Among the highlights (if I can call them highlights) Kings Of Edon is the best song in the album. It is the only song in which the orchestra works well and is the only song which can fit in a Secret Of The Runes or Theli, as bonus track of course. 2012 is a fairly enjoyable track and so is the opener. The rest of them are utter abominations. Low quality, orchestra with feather light rhythm guitars churning out basic level, mediocre riffs topped with vocals. Even the vocals get on the nerves after sometime. Then above all they try to make the music proggy. So in comes couple of epic numbers in the form of Land of Canaan and the utterly laughable closer, which actually are not at all epic but just barely manage to plod along by the numbers. Some heavy tracks are attempts like Kali Yuga III and Din but the fact that the rhythm guitars are as heavy as in a Bon Jovi album does not help them. 'Kali Yuga III', again a clean evidence of lack of ideas. There is actually nothing original going on here. Pretty much everything is recycled and whatever is recycled is pure crap. The rest are more of the same all twisted together in my memory.

Sometimes I seriously doubted while listening to the album whether I had accidentally put in the wrong album. I mean how could the band that released Of Darkness, Secret Of The Runes, Lepaca Kliffoth, Theli, Lemuria/Sirius B.... ever begin to compose so hideous music. Agreed that I was never a big fan of the consistency of a Therion album, but then the music would be so craftily arranged that I would be glued to it. If you want a true taste of this band's imagination and composing capabilities, listen to Secret Of The Runes. Not the album, but the bonus track called Summernight City, and just listen how they converted a sappy, pop anthem into a dark, mystical, occultic song. While on this album we find that the songs which are actually written to sound mysterious and occultic actually sound comical and poppy. Innovation, there is nothing of any kind on this album. The songs do not transport me to wherever and whatever their lyrics spoke off, as was the case with their earlier efforts. Instead I am sitting on my chair, yawning, scratching my head out of sleep, boredom frustration and what not other things wondering why and what am I listening to. So concluding, please do not buy this album because this the very epicenter of boredom and frustration.

A true piece of art! - 95%

kluseba, October 6th, 2010

I really like this album. After the brilliant "Lemuria/Sirius B" double album and the still solid "Gothic Kabbalah" which had its lengths and strengths, the band is now back and presents their best album since the innovating "Theli".

But attention, dear metal heads: While "Theli" was an album build on 75% on heavy and death metal and 25% symphonic and classic music, it is now the opposite on "Sitra Ahra". The "Miskolc Experience" and the line-up changes seem to have influenced the band to go even further in their connection of metal and classic. I was already afraid that the line-up changes may destroy the uniqueness of the band and make it go in another direction, but I am very happy to see that those line-up changes have been a fresh rebirth for the band and that Therion continues its journey towards the perfect symbiosis of metal dynamic and power and classical and symphonic intellectual elegance. When you listen to the album, you feel that this band exactly knows what they are doing and where they want to go. And that's why this album isn't a copy of the previous works as "Gothic Kabbalah" already began to repeat the style of "Lemuria/Sirius B", but a really fresh new beginning for the innovating and creative Swedish band.

Only the still brilliant opener "Sitra Ahra" which connects metal and classic equally and the darker, heavier short old school song "Din" remind a lot of the old style of the band.

Medieval, choral-influenced traditional songs as the harmonic "Hellequin", the Celtic and very powerful and happy "Cu Chulainn" or the on Arabian and Persian folklore based epic monster piece "Land of Canaan" - to just mention to 10 out of 10 songs - represent what Therion is today: an open-minded, cultural, historical classic band who plays well developed symphonic mini-operas with some minor metal influences.

The album makes its listener voyage and discover ancient cultures and their folklore and he or she becomes the stunning tourist who admires the amazing sightseeing tour. And after the tour, you have gotten so many interesting insights that you automatically want to voyage again and again and watch the photos of what you have seen over and over again. Once you have listened to the first four songs, you are not able to not finish this album, you get sucked into a maelstrom of exotic impressions, hypnotic melodies and the music creates a lot of images in your head. Therion makes you dream and even if the songs are very complex and elaborated, they have are so light and soft that you don't need more than one try to adore this album, to get into its atmosphere. The album is diversified and progressive without being complex, complicated or mixed-up. It is easy to listen too, but you still discover more and more elements after each hour of pleasure and the album grows more and more on you. Even the "weaker" songs on the album like " Unguentum Sabbati" which has the lack of the famous certain something or "2012" which begins brilliantly but never comes to the punching highlight after its brilliant introduction, fit perfectly with the rest of the album.

This harmonic album is surely nothing for the average metal fan, but Therion has never been a band for that kind of metal head. This album is for the more intellectual people who are not afraid of discovering classical opera and symphony elements, strange languages and exotic cultures and who really take their time to listen to an album as a whole work in peace and harmony. You must listen to it while you are lying on your bed, dreaming, discovering, taking your time, it is surely no music to listen to on your mp3-player on your way to the job in the morning. It is just like an opera: The music creates something visual and wants to tell a story and this album is more than just music, it is a concept, it is a compilation of images and words in perfect harmony, it is a voyage into the past: It is a piece of art and works as a whole. And it is certainly already now the best album done in 2010 to me.

Corroded artery occasionally spurts ripe blood - 57%

autothrall, September 17th, 2010

It's a safe assumption that Swedish mainstays have jumped the shark at this point, their best material long behind them, their last stretch of interesting work beginning to gather dust. Sure, Secret of the Runes, Lemuria and Sirius B all had their moments, but the previous album Gothic Kabbalah was average its best, lamentably lame for the remainder of its playtime. The problem really is that the band has become a caricature of what it once created: the fusion of dark, occult themes and symphonic overtures lanced through a fat metallic boil. The male and female choirs have grown stale like old bread, no longer feeling so fresh as they did in the days of a Theli or Vovin, and the band seems to be recanting themselves and not progressing forward. Stale bread might be suitable for starving dogs or the squirrels and crows that clutter your back lawn, but not for someone seeking a deeper musical inspiration.

The reason that Therion's progression is important, is that the band carved out their name upon such an inflated sense for exploration in sound, transforming their death metal roots Of Darkness... and Beyond Sanctorum into the slightly bewildering Gothic death/thrash masterpiece Lepaca Kliffoth and then into a more accessible, bigger budget productions that launched the band out of the underground and into the radar of Nightwish drones, Everquest addicts and closet Renaissance fairgoers the world wide. Truth be told, though, they were still putting out some good music, but that all changed with Gothic Kabbalah, which felt like some phoned in approximation of the band's former strengths, drowned in pomp and cliche. I might not have been the hugest fan of, say, a Deggial or Lemuria, but at least there I still recognized the craft of Christofer Johnsson and his troupe, deep at work. With Gothic Kabbalah, that all came to a roaring halt as the lame fairy metal vocals and such overtook the work.

I feel like Sitra Ahra continues along this same downward, weeping path, though the album as a whole is subtly stronger than its predecessor, successful in at least a few of its tracks. With all of the original lineup now long in the past, only Johnsson remains, surrounding himself with his latest traveling circus. Johan Koleberg of Lion's Share on the drums, Nalle Påhlsson of Treat and recent prog metallers Vindictiv, and guitarist Christian Vidal make up the core, with vocals contributed by Lori Lewis of Aesma Daeva, Snowy Shaw of Notre Dame, Dream Evil, King Diamond and so forth, and primarily Thomas Vikström, who fronted Candlemass on their worst album, along with several progressive metal oriented projects. Obviously, this is a metric shit ton of talent and experience, not selling short Christofer himself, who is the sun at the center of this mutant solar system.

Like previous Therion efforts, both the male and female vocals are contrasted between a pair of styles that provide for most of the album's 'diversity'. The male opera choirs and shrill female opera vocals are both executed well enough, as we've come to expect since the band dropped Theli in the 90s. Whether or not the actual lines are that interesting depends on the particular track, but the non-operatic vocals on the entire album are generally quite weak, from the acidic and goofy males to the standard fairy metal tripe of Lewis. Occasionally, you will hear additional voices in between these two sets of poles, usually acceptable, but the album is constantly cycling through highs and lows of brilliance and awkward, unformed ideas that should have been left in the Johnsson's belly to gestate before being shat out across the album. Below this, the music shifts between traditional metal with sporadic flavours of ethnic and progressive influence, woodwinds and so forth.

It's a giant mess, with a number of songs jumbled together like a jambalaya of suck. "Land of Canaan" in particular is a snoozefest of laughable constituents shoved together to prove the band's ability to drop on a dime through various genres, as much Billy Joel as Diamanda Galas. Hearing such a 10.5 minute monstrosity makes me long for a simpler time, when Johnsson himself performed Tom G. Warrior-like riffs and vocals and the band kicked ass upon a dark, mesmerizing platform. This track is simply folly, and so many unfortunately follow suit, like the forgettable and predictable "Cú Chulainn" or the not so epic progressive metal opener "Introduction/Sitra Ahra" with some pretty terrible female vocals that only occasionally border on welcome (it sounds like something Epica might write, but with a male opera singer guesting). Of course, the band drops in hints of power metal as they have since "The Wild Hunt" on Vovin, appearing here on the brief "Din", "Hellequin" or the often raging "Kings of Edom", which in parts is one of the best songs on this album.

I mentioned earlier that there were several effective compositions here, and that is the truth. I found myself somewhat submerged in "2012", which feels for the most part like a mid 90s Therion piece, despite the acidic, higher pitched vocals which counterbalance the shrill female backdrop and doomed atmosphere. This seems to gel together through its entirety, and I appreciated the Godzilla-like horn sections. "Unguentum Sabbati" makes the best use of Shaw's vocals and a dirty, pumping gait whilst the guitars and horns once more excel in unison, though there are a few puddles of weak sauce dotting its landscape. "The Shells Are Open" has the best, pure choral segments on the album and "Kali Yuga III" feels like Therion took a bite out of Senmuth's acid ethnic doom-prog and supplanted it back within its own fertility center to spawn a beautiful little offspring. "Din" rocks, even with the King Diamond wannabe vocals.

So, with half the album being a busted vein of scrotum tightening Gothic vampirella vaudevillian wretchedness, and the other half proof that Johnsson still has the muster to craft the carnal, occult mystique that made us adore his band in the first place, the ability to immerse oneself in this spectrum of sound will rely on just how apathetic you've been towards the last (shitty) record and all the superior work that came before it. There are bits and pieces for fans of almost any phase in this band's career, with the exception of the first two death metal records, but it very often clashes, with the band lurching from one style of music into the next, the only glue fixing them together being the vocals or production. Nothing feels so fresh or fulfilling as the band's evolution throughout the 90s, and to that extent it does seem to be playing it safe, treading little to no new ground. For about 20-30 minutes of Sitra Ahra, I sat with rapt attention like the rest of the squirrels and birds as they squabbled over the scraps being fed out, squandered against the lamer compositions, but too soon did I feel the urge to go inside and close the door on this forever.

-autothrall
http://www.fromthedustreturned.com